Cheap alternative to chewable bariatric advantage multi-vit??

dolfinluvr77
on 5/27/10 8:13 am - Moorhead, MN
I love the Bariatric Advantage Chewable Multi-Vitamins but I can't afford them anymore at $36 a bottle!!! Does anyone know of any cheaper alternatives?? I really like chewables b/c I can't stand swallowing all the vits we have to take in a single day. Plus, they taste good.
      Began my journey in 2008 at 246#....lost 111#...have regaind about 35#'s of which I am currently trying to rectify!
  
Alayna A.
on 5/27/10 8:29 am - Oakdale, MN
My bariatric MD always says the BA are like the cadillac of vitamins, we absorb them so much better than others. Do you get your BA vitamins online? If you join the auto refill club on BA.com they have free shipping and you can do the rewards program and they take a bunch of money off of your order for everything you spend. It works out to about 41 cents a day for the multi-vitamins without the tax.

I spent a lot of time looking for cheaper alternatives to BA, and finally it broke down to the BA were the best tasting for me and most convenient and supposedly the cadillac of vitamins so I figured I was worth it. I couldn't beat the convenience of them shipping it to me free whenever I was due to be running out.
~Alayna
Maintaining for 3-1/2yrs now!!
Pregnant and due February 9, 2012 with first child


candys
on 5/27/10 9:02 am
RNY on 11/24/09 with
Centrum chewables are pretty good. I take Centrum silver because I don't want added iron. I take 2 a day.
there but for the grace of God go I...
    
Lori J.
on 5/27/10 9:14 am - Minneapolis, MN
RNY on 04/15/03 with
I saw that Target had Vitafusion Gummy vitamins and calcium in their ad this week.  I have no idea what's in them or if they're any good, but it might be worth checking out.  I don't think I'd pay $36 for one bottle of vitamins, unless it had 1000 tabs!  I'm 7 years out and my labs are great and I've been using vitamins from Vitalady.com, Iherb.com and Costco.

Lori J.

It's better to be imperfectly happy than perfectly unhappy. 

dolfinluvr77
on 5/27/10 10:07 am - Moorhead, MN
Thanks! I will have to check those out...bring my BA bottle and compare the amounts of each vit. I do still have quite a few chewable calciums from BA. Just looking for a multi-vit b/c if I get nothing else in but that I'm usually ok.
Vitalady sold same kind of BA I was ordering online from BA for the same price...so not cheaper.
      Began my journey in 2008 at 246#....lost 111#...have regaind about 35#'s of which I am currently trying to rectify!
  
Judi J.
on 5/27/10 12:37 pm - MN

I think the Gummies don't have the right kind of A and some other stuff.
I used to take the Centrum silver because they tasted better than the regular Centrum to me.

A lot of people I know don't even use chewables anymore and their labs are fine. I like chewables just for the ease of taking them whenever.

If you go to non-chewables though you have way more options. Sams Club or Costco has Centrum equivalent multis

please don't do the gummies, you could wind up deficient in some stuff

vanish
on 5/27/10 9:22 am - MN
Lori - I love your tag line!  I'll have to remember that one
 RNY 12/28/09 
                      
Darla S.
on 5/27/10 12:40 pm - Hanover, MN
RNY on 04/27/07 with
My own perspective on the whole vitamin issue is - I don't have to like 'em, I just have to take 'em.  The Centrum chewables have done fine by me! 

As for calcium, I switch around a lot - some Viactive, some calcium citrate tablets, some of the gummies or what-have-you.  I like the BA cherry lozenges myself, but they are a bit spendy for me.  I just make sure I keep a variety handy, and so far- so good on the labs!

One interesting thing, tho - I've never been told to take iron, because I had a hysterectomy over 8 years ago.  But at my 3 year, I was told my levels are on the very low end of normal, so Dr. Wiita suggested I add one supplement every other day, or add a childrens vitamin with iron daily.  I chose the childrens, and went with Centrum Kids chewables.  But when I compared the label on that to the label on the "grown up" chewables - the 'amount per tablet' on everything is identical to the adult chewables! 
WTH???!!!


  Imperfect does not = unsuccessful

-Vii-
on 5/27/10 5:21 pm - MN
my Nutritionist said it was ok for me to keep taking the Flintstones Complete chewables.  As long as it says Complete they are fine.  I take 2 a day and I don't mind them at all...can get them at Walmart or Sam's Club.

Carolyn "Vii"

Lisa_Marie_
on 5/28/10 2:29 pm - Apple Valley, MN
RNY on 10/04/10 with
Here is a liquid vitamin that I found and was thinking about taking after surgery instead of the chewables.  I will run it by my doctor but I was curious what you guys would say.  Please take a look at what is in them and let me know.  I have also started to drink shakes with protein powder each morning.  Just three more months until I get my surgery :)  Here is the link to look at the vitamins...
http://www.proimageteam.com/24974/products/pvc.htm

Let me know what you think please.
Lori J.
on 6/1/10 4:08 am - Minneapolis, MN
RNY on 04/15/03 with
I don't think I would take these.  First of all there is way more stuff in these than you need including sugar.  Not a good thing for someone with an RNY, especially at first, some people dump at the sight of sugar.  The vitamin content itself is probably ok, I'm no expert, but the cost is way too high as well.  One month's worth is over $30.00 vs. a bottle of Flintstones or Centrum chewables is maybe around $5.00?  I personally would do the chewables until you can swallow normal pills.

Just my opinion...

Lori J.

It's better to be imperfectly happy than perfectly unhappy.