protein/fat/carb ratios in maintenance?

slrm2m2
on 7/22/12 6:14 am - Canada
 I know that the dieticians at my bariatric centre recommend a 40 protein/30 carb/30 fat ratio for your daily intake during the weight loss phase.  But I don't remember hearing anything about eating during maintenance.   Does this hold true as you go into maintenance and increase your calories?   How much is too much protein in terms of putting a strain on the kidneys?   I've just raised my calories to 1200 because I don't want to lose anymore weight and that would have me eating 120g of protein per day.  Is that too much?

Thanks for the advice!  
Sandy  Surgery Jan.18,2012 with Dr. Timothy Jackson at TWH.
  
    
Cicerogirl, The PhD
Version

on 7/22/12 6:25 am - OH
I still eat about the same 40/30/30 ratio (although I try to keep the protein closer to 50) that I was eating when I was losing.  I am maintaining at 5 years out.  I have not seen any evidence that just 120g of protein per day is anywhere near high enough to cause kidney problems.  I will say, though, that when i occasionally track my food intake for a few days just to be sure I am still " on track", it shows that I eat about 1400-1500 calories per day, am around that protein/fat/carb ratio, but I only eat 80-90g of protein per day... so different food choices can still maintain that ratio but with less protein in even more than 1200 calories.  On days when I have protein snacks other than my typical almonds, full fat cheese, or Greek yogurt, the calories are still about 1400 but the ratio changes to about 50/25/25.

Lora

 6 years out and maintaining 190 pounds lost!  

“You don't drown by falling in the water.  You drown by staying there.”

 

Larry Wassmann
on 7/22/12 6:30 am - Lacey, WA
RNY on 05/09/12
My manual says 70 percent protein and to eat it first, then 30 percent of anything else if I want. I only get 500-600 calories a day and can only take in about 2.5oz of solid food. A little more maybe 4oz of things like cottage cheese. But then again I am a long long way from maintenance and my NUT may change that along the way. RNY 5/9/12  

fb.png   Visit my Blog at  http://www.lwassmann.blogspot.com/                                

Cicerogirl, The PhD
Version

on 7/22/12 6:54 am - OH
Yeah, I would expect your NUT would drop the protein percentage once you are able to eat a larger volume of food and are taking in more calories...    If someone is eating just 1600 calories a day (lower than a lot of people, especially men, eat in maintenance) and 70% of that is protein, that would be over 1100 calories in protein alone, and if the protein is primarily low calorie things like poultry, fish, etc. that would be 160g of protein per day!

Lora

 6 years out and maintaining 190 pounds lost!  

“You don't drown by falling in the water.  You drown by staying there.”

 

nfarris79
on 7/22/12 7:11 am - Germantown, MD
 That sounds reasonable to me. My NUT recommends at 1200cal/day, we eat at least 80g protein, under 80g carbs and under 50g fat, but when one is eating 1400 cal/day for maintenece, the levels change to 80g protein, 130g carbs, and 60g fat. I pretty much stay under the carbs limit but often eat quite a bit more protein than 80g/day. 

First Full Marathon: Marine Corps 10/27/13 4:57:11, Half Marathon PR 2:04:43 at Shamrock VA Beach Half-Marathon, 12/2/12 First Half-Marathon 2:32:47, 5K PR  Run Under the Lights 5K 27:23 on 11/23/13, 10K PR 52:53 Pike's Peek 10K 4/21/13(1st timed run) Accumen 8K 51:09 10/14/12. 7  Half-Marathons finished


HW 267/SW 227/CW 130/ GW 140
     
 

H.a.l.a. B.
on 7/22/12 7:34 am
RNY on 05/14/08 with

What ever works.  I don't think there is one answer for all. For all of us it is trial and error. It will depend on a person, their weight, body shape and level of activity. Also - appetite,,

I can eat more calories but only when I do low carb.  And not all carbs are equal. Some will help me lose weight (like green veggies) while the same carbs from crackers - may cause weight gain.  
I don't exercise much - and I can maintain eating 6-7 times a day on a low carb (< 50-60) and high proteins diet.  
And that may change as we get older and farther from WLS.  

H.a.l.a RNY 5/14/2008    

Need to bitch?  or Rave?  To find new R&R - 3.0 group..- send a PM -  to get included...

"Failure is not falling down, It is not getting up once you fell..."

 "So pick yourself up, dust yourself off, and start all over again...." 

Pam T.
on 7/22/12 8:37 am - Saginaw, MI
 I keep the same ratio as I have since the beginning. I'm closing in on 5 years post-op and still shoot for 40% protein - 30-35% carbs - 25-30% fat.  I typically get over 100g protein per day from food (rarly do supplements unless I'm being lazy) and eat around 1200-1400 calories.

No, 120g protein is not too much.

My Recipe Index is packed full of yumminess!
Visit my blog: Journey to a Healthier Me  ...or my Website

The scale can measure the weight of my body but never my worth as a woman. ~Lysa TerKeurst author of Made to Crave

 

KittenLove
on 7/22/12 8:48 am - Around Knoxville, TN
RNY on 09/02/08 with
OMG!!!!! How awesome is it to see YOU?!?!

Numbers ROCK but this is about health and life - it's your decision, OWN IT!
Just when it gets the toughest, glory is won.

26.2 on 4/3/11 & 4/1/12
  

 

KittenLove
on 7/22/12 8:56 am - Around Knoxville, TN
RNY on 09/02/08 with
Isn't it awful that I never really look at ratios. Just grams overall... Protein in maint at least 75-80 but it usually ends up around 90.

Numbers ROCK but this is about health and life - it's your decision, OWN IT!
Just when it gets the toughest, glory is won.

26.2 on 4/3/11 & 4/1/12
  

 

exohexoh
on 7/22/12 9:02 am - West Chester, PA
 i'm the same way. my dietician never mentioned anything about ratios either, but i guess if you're watching the grams and calories it ends up where it should anyway

                                                                       <3 jen <3

               

                                    <3 starting weight: 252 <3 goal weight: 135 <3 current weight: 151 <3

                                      RNY: 9/27/10 <3 Extended Tummy Tuck w/hip & thigh lipo: 6/6/13

Cicerogirl, The PhD
Version

on 7/22/12 12:27 pm - OH
The only thing I count (and have ever counted since surgery) is protein.  I only know the ratio because I track a couple of days of food intake a couple of times a year just to see where I stand (and the tracker gives me the ratio), so I see nothing "awful" at all about not paying any attention.  Since I have been eating a lot of the same foods week after week after week for the past 5 years, most days I don't even actively count the protein.

Lora

 6 years out and maintaining 190 pounds lost!  

“You don't drown by falling in the water.  You drown by staying there.”