on 4/1/14 12:25 am
VSG on 05/12/14

Hi Everyone.  Im new to the forum scene.  I am in the process of having WLS.  I'm meeting with my surgeon on April 22nd to let him know which surgery I would like to have.  Im torn between the RNY or the Sleeve.  Ive done research and read what others have had to say regarding each surgery, but Im just having a difficult time deciding.  Im leaning towards the RNY because of less calories being absorbed by the body.  But I would appreciate any and all advise/opinions on this question.. Thankyou...

Cathy W.
on 4/1/14 12:54 am

After you meet with your surgeon, you'll have a better idea.  Your surgeon will talk with you, review your co-morbid conditions and medical history to help you make the decision best for you. 

If you haven't already, check out the RNY and VSG message boards.  Post on those boards about why members selected the surgery that they did. 

I had RNY but if the Sleeve had been an option for me when I had surgery, I don't know which one I would have selected. 

on 4/1/14 2:58 am
VSG on 05/12/14

Thanks for the info.  I'll definetly post on those boards as well.  Well, I met with the surgeon already and we discussed the pros and cons of each.  The 22nd is the date I need to give my decision. Thanks again..

Brad Special

on 4/1/14 1:31 am
VSG on 12/06/12 with

Yes talk to the surgeon and do your research. It all depends on the persons individual health factors as well. Just know that the absoption of less calories ends after 2 or 3 years.

on 4/1/14 2:56 am

RNYers absorb less calories AND nutrients after eating, have to take costly supplements, and have to get at least annual labs (bloodwork) done to keep everything in check. RNYers tend  to lose weight faster than Sleeves.

 “Let someone love you just the way you are – as flawed as you might be, as unattractive as you sometimes feel, and as unaccomplished as you think you are. To believe that you must hide all the parts of you that are broken, out of fear that someone else is incapable of loving what is less than perfect, is to believe that sunlight is incapable of entering a broken window and illuminating a dark room.”― Marc Hack

Ht:5'4 SW:268 CW:127.2 GW:125 RNY 06/09 Stomach/colon revision 11/13  

Sparklekitty, Science-Loving Derby Hag
on 4/2/14 2:16 am
RNY on 08/05/19

I have a sleeve, and my doctor also has me do a full set of bloodwork before appointments. (1 month, 3 month, 6 month, and then yearly once I hit that point.) I also have to take vitamins, perhaps not as many as someone who's has RNY-- but still a multi, iron, and B12 based on the results of my bloodwork.

Sparklekitty / Julie / Nerdy Little Secret (#42)
Roller derby - cycling - triathlon
VSG 2013, RNY conversion 2019 due to GERD. Trendweight here!

(deactivated member)
on 4/1/14 7:12 am