RNY vs VSG

I am having difficulty deciding between RNY and VSG.  I have my surgicial consultation today and not sure which way I should go...anyone have any insight?
Thanks!

I guess I should add more detail...I have a BMI >50.  I don't have diabetes or HBP.  I have sleep apnea and arthritis in the knees.  Other than that, I am pretty healthy.

My surgeon was the most helpful person in making my decision.  I also made an appointment with my PCP to discuss which surgery would be best for me - they aren't getting paid for the surgery - so a neutral medical professional is a good idea. 

Good luck with your decision.
Laura

Thanks Laura!

My decision was made easy in that insurance only covered RNY or the band. I knew I didn't want the band and couldn't afford any surgery on my own. I am VERY happy with the RNY.

Let your doctors help you make the best choice for you.

Martha

I thought I wanted a band until I met with my surgeon.  They can offer insight into what they think is best for your situation.  My BMI was over 50 and I had no co-morbities and was basically a healthy fat girl.  My doctor suggested RNY due to my destroyed metabolism and family history of obesity.  I am so glad I did it and have never regretted it.

My sister had the VSG two months before I had my RNY.  She was barely 100 lbs overweight.  She has done well with weight loss but hasn't completely changed her lifestyle so I hope she'll do good at maintaining.  She also suffers from food addiction so that is another demon she faces.  She has been very happy with her results and doesn't regret her decision.

Do your homework, let your surgeon guide you and pick what is best for you--this is a big decision for the rest of your life.

Kim

I'm like the post you've already received, my insurance made that decision for me. The insurance company will not pay for a VSG. The only choice I have is Lap Band or RNY. My surgeon seems to think the RNY is better because of the succuss rate verses Lap Band. So, I'm waiting for my RNY.

Your surgeon will be able to tell you what they think would work best for you.  I really wanted a VSG but insurance does not cover it unless it's in conjunction with an RNY or DS.  My surgeon feels that I wouldn't  see the results with a VSG that I would want and he recommended RNY anyway (which insurance does cover thankfully).

Thankfully my insurance covers 90% of the band, the RNY and the sleeve.  I have my surgical consult today so I am eager to hear what his suggestion will be.

I wasn't quite sure which surgery I wanted.
My surgeon recommended RNY because I was practically living on sugar.
I'm so happy I listened to him.
I now feel like I've kicked an addiction to sugar.
I know with any addiction I will always be in recovery but so far so good.