Soup's On

RebeccaElise
on 3/20/13 8:12 am - Quincy, MA

I'm about 14 weeks PO now and doing pretty well with the food and vitamins and water. I have a question about soup, though. Since it's mostly liquid and I'm supposed to wait 30 minutes after eating solids to have liquids, how do you have soup as a part of a meal? Do you eat it first, and then have the solids? Put the solids into the soup?

 

The meal I have planned for the evening is butternut squash soup, wilted spinach, and a little pork loin. How should I approach this?

Come visit me on my blog, Through a Cooking Glass! I talk about my journey through WLS and learning to live, cook, and eat on the other side.  

        

camelon
on 3/20/13 8:36 am

I was wondering the same thing about eating cereal?

chickenoregg
on 3/20/13 8:56 am - Portland, OR
RNY on 02/26/13
Three weeks post-op here. Wondering the same thing about soup and cereal.
Seems like you could eat it all together as long as you feel full enough that you don't eat more than you should. But I dunno!

Surgery (RNY) scheduled for Feb 26, 2013

    
Sherrie P.
on 3/20/13 9:26 am
RNY on 02/06/13

The reason we don't eat and drink at the same time is so we don't wash food out of our pouch, because without a pyloric valve any more it will flow on through.  Thus you will get hungry  -- because you have washed all the food out of your stomach. 

If you eat soup - or cereal, just be aware that you may not be full for long and you can probably eat more than you expect.

 

Revision Lapband to RNY 2-6-2013   HW: 286  Pre-Op Diet: 277  Surgery Day: 265  Goal: 155  CW: 155

Plastic surgery 8/28/2014: Brachioplasty, mastopexy, & abdominoplasty.

Plastic surgery 1/27/2015: Butt Lift

    

noftessa0401
on 3/20/13 9:29 am - San Diego, CA
RNY on 12/27/12

It depends on the soup.  If it has a broth and chunky stuff in it (like a stew), then I do the broth first (like a liquid), and then eat the chunky stuff.  If it is a creamy soup, then I eat that and then eat the rest of the meal.  In your meal example, I would eat the soup, then the pork and spinach.  You might get more calories than you originally plan for or are used to, but for me, I struggle to remember to eat, so more calories is not a problem.

HW: 274 | SW: 232 | CW: 137 | Goal: 145 (ticker includes a 42 pound loss pre-op) | Height: 5'4"

M1: -24 (205) | M2: -14 (191) | M3: -11 (180) | M4: -7 (173) | M5: -7 (166) | M6: -8 (158) | M7: -11 (147) | M8: -2 (145) | M9: -3 (142) | M10: -2 (140) | M11: -4 (136) | M12: -2 (134) | M13: -0 (134) | M14: -3 (131) | M15: +4 (135) | M16: +2 (137)

RebeccaElise
on 3/20/13 11:53 am - Quincy, MA

Well, I figured I could control the calories by controlling the portion size. If I'm eating 3/4 C. soup, it's still just 3/4 C. If I then eat 2-3 oz. lean pork loin and 1/4 wilted spinach, it's still just those amounts. I agree, though, that it seems like it would be best to treat the soup like a "1st course" in this case. For lunch tomorrow, I'm planning on some tomato soup with protein powder in it and maybe an apple (they really fill me up) so I'll do the same thing tomorrow.

Come visit me on my blog, Through a Cooking Glass! I talk about my journey through WLS and learning to live, cook, and eat on the other side.  

        

BWB
on 3/20/13 1:26 pm, edited 3/20/13 1:26 pm

I think you will be fine with that but you have to consider the tomato soup as a liquid.  You might want to take some small snacks to supplement it later in the day.

 

I should add that I fix chunky soups quite often and I load them up with chicken, beef, or ham with cheese, veggies, mushrooms, and onions.  My last labs were better than they have ever been.  

               
Most Active
What's on your Monday Menu?
Queen JB · 41 replies · 542 views
What's on your Tuesday Menu?
Queen JB · 38 replies · 526 views
What's on your Wednesday Menu?
Queen JB · 28 replies · 414 views
What's on your Thursday Menu?
Queen JB · 26 replies · 296 views
What?s on your Sunday menu?
Melody P. · 2 replies · 128 views
Recent Topics
What's on your Thursday Menu?
Queen JB · 26 replies · 296 views
What's on your Wednesday Menu?
Queen JB · 28 replies · 414 views
What's on your Tuesday Menu?
Queen JB · 38 replies · 526 views
What's on your Monday Menu?
Queen JB · 41 replies · 542 views
×