VET Question: Acid vs. Hunger

Chrissy W.
on 1/23/14 8:30 am - Indianapolis, IN
VSG on 07/01/13

Hello, you lovely VSGers. I have a quick question for our Vets (or anyone further out that I am, really)... I have been experiencing some wicked hunger pangs over the last week. This is NOT head hunger. I'm not having carb cravings either. I carb detoxed several days ago, thinking that was my problem, but it's still there... I'm talking (loud) gurgling stomach that feels like a bottomless pit. I did some searching here and came across a few posts that talked about increased acid mimicking hunger. Has anyone else physically experienced this? I'm thinking that it's not actual hunger as I've been pretty burpy as well. It's about to drive me Up. The. Wall. I've started getting HANGRY!

And FYI, I am on a pretty strong PPI, Dexilant. I have an appointment with my surgeon on Monday and I will be discussing this with him, but I'm beginning to think that I should ask to try a different PPI... Also, as an FYI. I've also read that ulcers can mimic hunger, but I had an endoscopy less than 2 months ago and everything looked fine.

I've sent a couple of PMs, but now let's hear from the masses!

VSG 7/1/13 with Dr. Jack Rutledge 28 y/o female - 5'10" - HW: 298GW: 174 - SW: 290 (-8) - M1: 262 (-28) - M2: 247 (-15) - M3: 235 (-12) - M4: 228 (-7 ~First Stall: almost 2 wks~) - M5: 218 (-10) - M6: 209 (-9) - M7: 199 (-10) Onederland on 1/31 - M8: 196 (-3) 100 lb total loss on 2/2 - M9: 192.6 (-3.4) - M10: 188.6 (-4) - M11: 182 (-6.6) - M12: 175.6 (-6.4) - M13: 173.8 (-1.8) CW (7/8/15): 167 - GOAL reached in 1 Year and 25 Days! - TOTAL WL - 131 lbs  

Tracy D.
on 1/23/14 9:40 am - Papillion, NE
VSG on 05/24/13

Yes, yes, yes - still dealing with acid issues and it absolutely feels like I'm starving :-(   Try a different PPI.  I'm told that eventually this dies down.  Fingers crossed...

 Tracy  5'3"     HW: 235  SW: 218  CW: 132    M1: -22  M2: -13  M3: -12  M4: -9  M5: -8   M6: -10   M7: -4

 Goal reached in 7 months and 1 week

 Lower Body Lift w/Dr. Barnthouse 7-8-15

   

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

Chrissy W.
on 1/23/14 10:47 am - Indianapolis, IN
VSG on 07/01/13

This goes away?? Meaning that it goes away because you're taking a PPI, or it just goes away? I REALLY hope it just goes away! This sucks.

VSG 7/1/13 with Dr. Jack Rutledge 28 y/o female - 5'10" - HW: 298GW: 174 - SW: 290 (-8) - M1: 262 (-28) - M2: 247 (-15) - M3: 235 (-12) - M4: 228 (-7 ~First Stall: almost 2 wks~) - M5: 218 (-10) - M6: 209 (-9) - M7: 199 (-10) Onederland on 1/31 - M8: 196 (-3) 100 lb total loss on 2/2 - M9: 192.6 (-3.4) - M10: 188.6 (-4) - M11: 182 (-6.6) - M12: 175.6 (-6.4) - M13: 173.8 (-1.8) CW (7/8/15): 167 - GOAL reached in 1 Year and 25 Days! - TOTAL WL - 131 lbs  

Tracy D.
on 1/23/14 9:47 pm - Papillion, NE
VSG on 05/24/13

I mean that for many people, over time, the excess acid production dies down and they are able to wean off the PPIs.   I'm doing that right now but still have to pop Tums a couple times a day.  However, I have a good friend who had the DS and she's been taking Protonix for years and doesn't anticipate ever getting off it.  

 Tracy  5'3"     HW: 235  SW: 218  CW: 132    M1: -22  M2: -13  M3: -12  M4: -9  M5: -8   M6: -10   M7: -4

 Goal reached in 7 months and 1 week

 Lower Body Lift w/Dr. Barnthouse 7-8-15

   

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

Chrissy W.
on 1/23/14 10:49 pm - Indianapolis, IN
VSG on 07/01/13

Hmmm. I really hope I'm able to wean off eventually. One less medication would be nice. 

VSG 7/1/13 with Dr. Jack Rutledge 28 y/o female - 5'10" - HW: 298GW: 174 - SW: 290 (-8) - M1: 262 (-28) - M2: 247 (-15) - M3: 235 (-12) - M4: 228 (-7 ~First Stall: almost 2 wks~) - M5: 218 (-10) - M6: 209 (-9) - M7: 199 (-10) Onederland on 1/31 - M8: 196 (-3) 100 lb total loss on 2/2 - M9: 192.6 (-3.4) - M10: 188.6 (-4) - M11: 182 (-6.6) - M12: 175.6 (-6.4) - M13: 173.8 (-1.8) CW (7/8/15): 167 - GOAL reached in 1 Year and 25 Days! - TOTAL WL - 131 lbs  

emelar
on 1/23/14 9:44 am - TX

Sounds like acid to me too.  Sometimes you have to experiment with dosages and different versions of PPIs to hit on the one that'll work.  Short term, take a few TUMS or a pepcid in addition to the dexilant until you see your surgeon.

Chrissy W.
on 1/23/14 10:47 am - Indianapolis, IN
VSG on 07/01/13

Good call. I wasn't thinking about taking Pepcid. I'll be doing that pronto.

VSG 7/1/13 with Dr. Jack Rutledge 28 y/o female - 5'10" - HW: 298GW: 174 - SW: 290 (-8) - M1: 262 (-28) - M2: 247 (-15) - M3: 235 (-12) - M4: 228 (-7 ~First Stall: almost 2 wks~) - M5: 218 (-10) - M6: 209 (-9) - M7: 199 (-10) Onederland on 1/31 - M8: 196 (-3) 100 lb total loss on 2/2 - M9: 192.6 (-3.4) - M10: 188.6 (-4) - M11: 182 (-6.6) - M12: 175.6 (-6.4) - M13: 173.8 (-1.8) CW (7/8/15): 167 - GOAL reached in 1 Year and 25 Days! - TOTAL WL - 131 lbs  

themexcellentone
on 1/23/14 12:21 pm
VSG on 07/08/13 with

You know I'm not a vet by a long shot, but when it gets this bad for me, I have taken to popping a chewy Tums.  It seems to settle things down a bit.  When it gets REALLY bad, I take 20 mg Pepcid.

VSG by Nick Nicholson in 2013. Revised to DS 2/23/2023 by Chad Carlton.

Chrissy W.
on 1/23/14 10:50 pm - Indianapolis, IN
VSG on 07/01/13

I'm definitely going to try to Pepcid today when things start getting gurgly. 

VSG 7/1/13 with Dr. Jack Rutledge 28 y/o female - 5'10" - HW: 298GW: 174 - SW: 290 (-8) - M1: 262 (-28) - M2: 247 (-15) - M3: 235 (-12) - M4: 228 (-7 ~First Stall: almost 2 wks~) - M5: 218 (-10) - M6: 209 (-9) - M7: 199 (-10) Onederland on 1/31 - M8: 196 (-3) 100 lb total loss on 2/2 - M9: 192.6 (-3.4) - M10: 188.6 (-4) - M11: 182 (-6.6) - M12: 175.6 (-6.4) - M13: 173.8 (-1.8) CW (7/8/15): 167 - GOAL reached in 1 Year and 25 Days! - TOTAL WL - 131 lbs  

grayC
on 1/23/14 9:53 am
VSG on 05/01/13

I have been ravenous too!!

i mean like white knuckling it, fighting to raid the fridge,pantry whatever...

I was also thinking it may be acid....

the funny or weird thing is, I'm fine not hungry or anything until either after my first meal

or sometimes when that  1st meal holds me I get insanely hungry around 3-4 pm.

   

        
Most Active
Expired Optifast Question
Freewheeler · 2 replies · 61 views
×