Gail: I was convinced I wanted to have the Lap RNY until I spoke with my surgeon. He said he would do it (and had done plenty at the patient's request), but that he much prefers the open. For one, the surgery is much more precise (easier to work when a patient is all the way opened up, rather than looking at everything through a t.v. monitor), the staples are closer together, and the pouch can be made a bit smaller. He said that the increase in leaks/complications is much higher with Lap, as a result (less precision in placing the staples). After that, I was convinced that Open RNY was the way to go. As far as recovery, yes, I'm sure the open must be a longer recovery -- from what I've read, at least. I did great following mine, but was pretty sore for the first 5-7 days. After that, I felt good, but I was tired enough to take my entire 4 weeks of leave from work. ANYWAY, if you have any more questions, please feel free to e-mail me! Good luck in your decision.