might have to have a RNY stomach?

Well, he's painting you a possible reality and getting your consent to make adjustments if need be.  He knows what you WANT, and will do everything he can to safely give that to you.   Yours is the perfect example of how that whole "less invasive" theory of the LapBand is blown to buts when the band has issues like slippage and erosion.  They don't take into account the real damage that can occur from band complications.  it's SO much more than removing a barrette out of your hair.