The red dress definitely it brings out the beautiful features of your face much more than the other dress. for what it is worth you don't need a shawl with it either it looks great just the way it is!
LOVE the red dress, the black washes you out. You could make a really gorgeous drape from fabric. I saw some nice red sheer material with rhinestones on it at Joann's. With the 40% off coupon, would be super cheap.
Has anyone told you yet that You looking smashing in the red dress? LOL- Yup it has my vote too- very flattering with your coloring! Congrats on your Emmy!
5'2" - High Weight=224 / Current=145 / My Goal= 130