Best Protein Drink for Best Price?

susantampa
on 1/29/09 9:49 pm - Lutz, FL

All,

My nutrutionist sells protein shakes for a pretty penny - and they're high in protein, low in carbs, but I am not paying that price for something I'm drinking so often. (2xper day)

What is the advice out there as far as best brand for us post-ops to buy? I went to GNC and got Wheybolic Extreme 60 - and it's a little higher in carbs but the guy said the ingredients are isolates so it makes it easier for the body to absorb.

Could I please get some suggestions as far as what has worked? I noticed this has soy in it and I should not be having soy because I have thyroid issues (had a thyroidectomy in Feb last year). My weight loss is slow and i'm sure that's partly why.

Thanks in advance,
Susan

Karen The Papaya
Queen

on 1/29/09 10:05 pm - somewhere
I only drink 1 a day as creamer in my coffee at work so I get the EAS AdvantEdge Carb Control ones... 17 gms of protein and 2 gms net carbs...    you can get them at Sam's Club or Costco sometimes in a 24 pack or at Wally World in a 4 or 6 pack....

Life is tough, but my God is TOUGHER
"There is more to life than increasing its speed.? Gandhi
The Greatest Pleasure In Life Is Doing What People Say You Cannot  Do....

377/331/198/175 Highest/WLS/Current/Goal
 

Robin W.
on 1/29/09 10:23 pm - Franklin, OH
I also like the EAS RTD if you want a powder mix you could try Body Fortress.  You can get it at WalMart.  I use 4 oz water and 6 ice cubes put it in the blender and drink.
Good Luck,
Robin

4'10" - 47 I'm short but not petite and I will weigh more than a 5th grader
Start weight 220 
"Be who you are and say what you feel because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind"  Dr. Seuss

Our Lady of the Holy
Rollers

on 1/29/09 11:20 pm
 Personally, I think its a real conflict of interest for a nut to be selling any one product.

My nut gives me lists of 'acceptable' products, and actually does research if I send her a product she is unfamiliar with. 

 my nut!!!!

-----------------------------------------

Our Lady of the Holy Rollers

That's not a tiara. I just bedazzle my horns.

H.A.L.A B.
on 1/30/09 1:30 am
Vitamin Shoppe has a great selection of different protein shakes and good prices for some of them.  Unfortunately, sometimes you get what you paying for.  meaning, the cheapest protein powder may have too many additives, and not enough of the "good" stuff.  Sure they might be OK, but do you really paying for what you need?

I think that EAS RTD has soy protein in it.  Not sure, but please check that.

Muscle milk RTD, have mostly whey, or milk protein. 

Please remember, that you can always return (if you have your receipt) the protein you bought in GNC even if you open it (since it has soy - you may not want to use it).

I use Unjury (good quality - a bit pricey),  "Designer Whey"  protein is fair, and it is less expensive. 
They are so many brands, and so many choices... try to get some that you like and that have the proteins that our body needs.  FYI for every 1 can (large one) of Designer Whey I buy 1 can of Unjury (unflavored) to make sure I get the quality and pricing matched.  Living and feeding ourselves is expensive. 

Hala. RNY 5/14/2008; Happy At Goal =HAG

"I can eat or do anything I want to - as long as I am willing to deal with the consequences"

"Failure is not falling down, It is not getting up once you fell... So pick yourself up, dust yourself off, and start all over again...."

susantampa
on 1/30/09 4:02 am - Lutz, FL
Where do you purchase your Unjury? I think I may take this stuff back. The salesman was very informative when it came to return policy.

I have used the EAS but wanted something with even more protein in it for my servings.

I have heard Unjury is good - can you buy that in stores?

Thanks,
Susan
Nancy O.
on 1/30/09 4:21 am - Old Lyme, CT
 You can only purchase online.

http://www.unjury.com/

 71 lb lost pre-op   Abdominoplasty & Panniculectomy Dec 4th, 2009
H.A.L.A B.
on 1/30/09 4:46 am
I buy mine in a store in SC  (My doc offce step up a store for pre and post bariatric patience - great idea- great resource center), but you can buy it on line.  And they are very good if you need to return.

Buy some samples from them (the flavored ones) try them and then buy what you like.
I only use Unjury unfavared.  But I get nausea so easy, and most comercial powders are too sweet for me.  So far i found some that are OK. 

Most of the time I mix 1/2 -1/2 flavored -unflavored, and with enough water or coffee, I get the taste I can drink.
Good luck.

Check Vitammin Shoppe- if you have one in your area.  Thy are great (at least in my area).

Hala. RNY 5/14/2008; Happy At Goal =HAG

"I can eat or do anything I want to - as long as I am willing to deal with the consequences"

"Failure is not falling down, It is not getting up once you fell... So pick yourself up, dust yourself off, and start all over again...."

Nancy O.
on 1/30/09 4:00 am - Old Lyme, CT
 I use unjury, good quality whey protein. If you sign up for their autoship program you get 15% off and if you order more than 6 you get free shipping, That helps. The nice thing is you can easily change the autoship program based on what you have.

Nancy

 71 lb lost pre-op   Abdominoplasty & Panniculectomy Dec 4th, 2009
kiradot
on 1/30/09 4:31 am
You might want to try out some samples before commiting to a big tub.

www.chikenutrition.com
www.unjury.com
www.bariatriceating.com
www.vitalady.com

All these sell samples or sample packages.

Personally I mainly use the Champion Whey because I can buy it locally at my Vitamin Shoppe and it is just as good (to me) as the other "regular" flavors (chocolate, vanilla, etc)

If you have a vitamin shoppe near you I have a 20% coupon I can forward you (only good in stores though)...

Their Champion is $45 for a 5# tub which has 71 servings (each with 24g of protein).  I mix it with 6 oz milk for an added protein boost but you could do it with water.  This works out to 63.4 cents per shake (+ cost of optional milk)

Amanda 5'10"  346/316/158/175 (start/surgery day/current/tentative goal)

Somewhere inside me, there is a fat girl just dying to get back out. I mostly just try to keep her subdued with sugar free pudding, but she's not amused.

Most Active
What's on your Monday menu?
ladygodiva1228 · 12 replies · 222 views
What's on your Tuesday Menu
Mkess · 5 replies · 125 views
Finally Friday's Menu
ladygodiva1228 · 5 replies · 129 views
Recent Topics
Finally Friday's Menu
ladygodiva1228 · 5 replies · 129 views
What's on your Tuesday Menu
Mkess · 5 replies · 125 views
×