Difference whey isolate vs. veg protein

Darcy S.
on 5/6/12 11:49 pm - Clinton, CT
Do we absorb veggie proteins as well as whet isolate proteins? Arbonne has protein shakes but contain veggie proteins like pea. Will we still absorb the benefits of the protein and absorb it?

 Decision made weight 265  SW 249 CW 153  9/4/12 next goal 145lbs  OMG                                

poet_kelly
on 5/7/12 1:55 am - OH
The problem is that pea protein (or rice protein, or other vegetable proteins) are not complete proteins.  So no, you would not absorb them as well, not very well at all.  Now, if you  mix those protein powders with something like skim milk, you'd be making a complete protein.  And some vegetable-based protein powders may contain a combination of proteins that make a complete protein.  Your best bet, if you are interested in using one of those, is to contact the company and ask for the PDCAAS score of the product.

Proteins can all be scored on a scale called the PDCAAS (I forget what that stands for, sorry).  It's a scale of 1 to 100, and whey isolate gets a sore of 100.  So does an egg.  That's the best.  Those protein shots that are mostly collagen protein with a little bit of whey thrown in usually score about 30 or so.  Which is bad. 

So anyway, if you ask the company for the PSCAAS score, if it's close to 100, then it's a good choice.  If not, then it's not a good choice.  If they won't or can't tell you the score, I would not trust their products.

View more of my photos at ObesityHelp.com          Kelly

Please note: I AM NOT A DOCTOR.  If you want medical advice, talk to your doctor.  Whatever I post, there is probably some surgeon or other health care provider somewhere that disagrees with me.  If you want to know what your surgeon thinks, then ask him or her.    Check out my blog.

 

Darcy S.
on 5/7/12 7:04 am - Clinton, CT
Thanks Kelly!!! You always sum it up so clearly!!! OH should be paying you as their voice of reason and information !!!!!
Most Active
Recent Topics
×