What to do when you miss the TASTE of a food?

I use Torani or Da Vinci syrups in my plain greek yogurt and making recipes from Eggface's blog.  I found a great place to get them other than on line.  Jungle Jims Market has probably 50 different flavors.  The bottles are big so if I have never tried a flavor and I don't like it, like my peppermint flavor, your stuck with a big bottle.  They are about $5 a bottle. There are 2 locations in Cincinnati, OH.  Sam's Club has the most popular flavors: Vanilla, Hazelnut and Carmel.  They are my go to flavors. 

I use sugar free or no sugar added jellies and jams. Just a small 1/2 Tbsp is good enough for me. Usually a little Truvia cuts the tartness of the yogurt.