carb counting "net" or total?

NorthernStar
on 11/30/12 10:44 pm - London, Canada
RNY on 06/25/12

I count total carbs and aim for 30 gr/day but I keep an eye to net carbs if I go a bit higher. I'm not a stickler if I went to 40 or a bit over if it's from veggies or increased fibre. I was reading in one of Lyle Macdonald's books that even though fibre is not absorbed the same way non-fibrous carbs are, you body still does absorb some even if it's just a little less. So with that in mind, I do look to total carbs.

*Lindsey*

Keeping off 133 lbs since 2012!

Referral to Bariatric Registry: May 2011   /   Surgery (HRRH): June 25, 2012         

Heathergetbetter
on 11/30/12 10:50 pm - Trenton, ON, Canada
RNY on 05/02/12

I've been careful with my food tracking, but I just added fibre as an item to track in Sparkpeople so I can keep a better eye on that now.

I'll be keeping a better eye on the carbs now.  

Dr Ref: Sept 9th '10, Dr. Follow up (file lost in bulk transfer) Aug '11Pre-surg Asmt Ottawa: Dec 9th '11File Transf to HRH -another bulk transf Bypass class: Feb 2 '12 Surgeon Consult: Feb 8 '12    Dietician: Feb 8 '12   Soc Wrkr: Feb 8 '12 Nurse: Feb 8 '12 Internist: Mar 9 '12  Surgeon: Apr 4 '12 Opti:Apr 18 '12 SURGERY: May 2 '12    
thunderhand
on 11/30/12 10:58 pm - mississauga, Canada
VSG on 06/11/12

Pat is correct     Only absorbed carbs count, so you don't count fibre or sugar alcohols

your body passes them , the are not absorbed so should not be counted towards your total.

ShallowGirl
on 12/1/12 2:04 am - Richmond Hill, Canada
RNY on 06/22/12

I know Weigh****chers at one point tried a carb counting thing, then had to amend it to say "it doesn't matter how much fiber per serving, you can only deduct 4 grams of fiber" because fatties, of course, were eating tons of high fiber high sugar foods thinking they netted out to no carbs.  

So I would say be careful of the "net" concept.

Intellectually of course, this is impossible.

   

The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams. Eleanor Roosevelt    

Heathergetbetter
on 12/1/12 4:52 am - Trenton, ON, Canada
RNY on 05/02/12

True, everything in reason. At least the fibre increase will cut down on how much metamucil, milk of mag or colace I need to take. lol

Dr Ref: Sept 9th '10, Dr. Follow up (file lost in bulk transfer) Aug '11Pre-surg Asmt Ottawa: Dec 9th '11File Transf to HRH -another bulk transf Bypass class: Feb 2 '12 Surgeon Consult: Feb 8 '12    Dietician: Feb 8 '12   Soc Wrkr: Feb 8 '12 Nurse: Feb 8 '12 Internist: Mar 9 '12  Surgeon: Apr 4 '12 Opti:Apr 18 '12 SURGERY: May 2 '12    
Most Active
Recent Topics
×