What is a good scale brand?

http://www.amazon.com/Eatsmart-Precision-Bathroom-Technology -440-Pounds/dp/B0032TNPOE/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1336657706& sr=8-2

I absolutely LOVE this scale. Its cheap and has over 3,000 5 stars on amazon! It has not been inaccurate since I got it and is way better then my last one! Good luck.

Is it consistent if you step on it more than once at a time?

My "new" WW scale is better than my old one but it almost never remains consistent when I step on it more than once. It also changes depending on WHERE on it I step.

I'd really like something at least a little more foolproof. :)

Yes :) It is always the same.

Cool. I've been reading some of the reviews and am pretty much convinced that this will be my next scale. Thank you!!!  :)

I did a lot of research on this, and the scale I decided on was a SECA (model 813).   It's always consistent, and measures up with my surgeon's BMI scale.

http://www.seca.com/english/us/home/products/details/seca/pr oduct/digital_personal_scales_274/seca_813_robusta/

EatSmart? Precision Plus Digital Bathroom Scale PHENOMENAL scale and even better customer service.

The EatSmart Precision Plus is our newest high capacity, ultra accurate digital bathroom scale. The slim, ergonomic design fits perfectly into any surroundings and oversized non-slip platform safely allows weights up to 440 pounds (one of the highest capacities on the market). At over 15 inches wide this scale will fit anyone comfortably. Also, the Precision Plus allows you to simply step on and instantaneously get your weight on an extra large 4.3" LCD display.

Features

EatSmart "Step-On" Technology - Get instant readings! No more tapping scale to turn on.
Large 4.3" LCD display with cool blue backlight - Easy to read from any distance.
4 High Precision Sensors - Consistent and accurate measurement
2 Measurement Modes: Pounds / Kilos
Graduation Increments of .2 lbs. / .1kg
Max Weight: 440 lbs / 200 kgs
Sturdy oversized 12" x 15.5" platform
Auto Calibrated; Includes 2 AAA batteries

Just a quick tip for any of the digital scales:  Your scale needs to stay in the exact same FLAT place in order for it to be accurate.  Carpet won't work.  Even the uneveness of my linoleum in the bathroom makes it barely unstable enough to be inaccurate.  Find a good, flat place where there is absolutely no wobble, and leave it there.  Someone even suggested having a piece of plywood cut to put under your scale so it is absolutely level.