Maggie Goes on A Diet: Controversial Children's Book Aimed at Overweight Kids, plus Keith...

M M
on 8/24/11 10:34 pm
 

Maggie Goes on A Diet: Controversial Children's Book Aimed at Overweight Kids, plus Keith Ablow is a DOUCHE.

Listen to this article. Powered by Odiogo.com

 

Screen shot 2011-08-25 at 8.26.35 AMMy first thought when viewing this news piece about the new kids' book:  "Maggie Goes on A Diet" was--  

"WHAT A GREAT WAY to get eyeballs to your OTHER books."  Right?  Make enough people angry or inspired -- we might go check out what else you've written.  It always works.

I can't get the video code to stick here, so go watch it, note please that the author is also Of Size Himself.

Dr. Keith Ablow supports this book, while being an asshole!  

Maggie Goes on a Diet, a new book by children's author Paul Michael Kramer, is drawing fire from those who believe it inappropriately focuses children on their weight and, by doing so, could lead to eating disorders. In the book, Maggie, a 14-year-old girl who is very overweight and has a negative self-image goes on a diet, works hard at it, loses weight and becomes a soccer star at school. She likes herself better, so the story ends happily-ever-after.

The same people criticizing Paul Michael Kramer and his Maggie Goes on a Diet are the people handing out ribbons and trophies to their kids whether they win or lose.

They're the people who are letting their kids use Facebook and disseminate mini-reality-bending, narcissism-inducing autobiographies of themselves to hundreds of fake "friends."

They're the people who are buying candy and ice cream for their overweight sons and daughters because saying "no" might injure them in some mysterious way that has never been proven—ever.

These are the people who also, by the way, fuel America's false economy with fake stimulus packages and bailouts and the printing of fake currency.

Maggie is a brave 14-year-old taking charge of her nutritional status, her weight and her life.

I think she's a fabulous role model—far better than the size 20 women who go on talk shows and lie about how happy they are with their bodies. And Paul Michael Kramer is a brave author for bringing her to life.

Hopefully, some of those Americans who would rather hear that everything will be okay as long as we tell every child how perfect she is, will actually read his book, too.

Read more: http://www.foxnews.com/health/2011/08/23/psychiatrist-promot es-controversial-diet-book-for-kids/#ixzz1W2iCJt8V

Heather :o)
on 8/24/11 11:06 pm
Dieting as a child was what paved the way for disordered eating and obesity in my future. I remember being 14 and I had a friend from Pakistan who had a few lbs to lose and her father forbid a diet telling her when she was 18 she could do what she wanted but for now he would just cook and buy healthy things. I thought he was so unreasonable, now in hindsight he was a smart man.

I bet my childhood friend has not spent her life in a diet yo yo like I did starting at 8 yrs old.
Believe nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it, no matter if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense. - Buddha
Karen M.
on 8/24/11 11:51 pm - Mississauga, Canada
My thoughts EXACTLY Heather.  I was on diets from the age of 6 - and we can all tell how well THAT worked for me! (not)  Not to mention the ever-dwindling self-esteem due to "not losing enough" or "not being thin enough" in my well-meaning parents' eyes. 

This book is apparently geared for children aged 4 - 8 years.  Whether well-meaning or not, I would have been devastated to be the recipient of this book.  I actually emailed the fox news article link to Dr. Yoni Freedhoff, author of the "Weighty Matters" web site.  His response - "horrifying".

 

Karen

Ontario Recipes Forum - http://www.obesityhelp.com/group/ontario_recipes/

jenflock
on 8/24/11 11:56 pm - TN
This book looks like crap.  As a parent of a severely overweight child I can empathise with parents and the child ( I was a huge kid).  I have so many fears about what do do for my daughter to ensure that she is healthy and self loving. I have banned junk from my home in an effort to only have yummy healthy options available. and health meals are a given daily.  She still continues to gain weight.  I'm at a loss as to what to do, have been to doctors and dieticians etc.  This book wont help because it just isn't reality based. healthy choices help...diets do not. or I never would have needed my DS to save my life.
    
Karen M.
on 8/25/11 12:00 am - Mississauga, Canada
I really feel for you as a parent.  I am forever grateful that my 20 year old son did not inherit my body-type, metabolism and weight issues.  I've often thought over the past few years how I would have handled it if he had been obese.  I know there wouldn't have been imposed diets, as my parents tried to do to help.  I think offering healthy choices and leading by example are an excellent start.  I'm glad to hear you've investigated medical and nutritional avenues as well.   I wish you both well.

 

Karen

Ontario Recipes Forum - http://www.obesityhelp.com/group/ontario_recipes/

jenflock
on 8/25/11 5:31 am - TN
I appreciate the positive feedback.  She has some medical issues that are as of now unresolved becasue they are undiagnosed.  My daughter has chronic loose BMs several times daily that the smell would peel the paint off the walls.  The odor linders horribly to her and the room.  I know there is an issue with her bowels but in the Dr's office I'm the crazy mom.  I've tried to get into a specialist but without a referral its pretty much a mess.  I'm thinking her stomach being swelled up is bloating as much as chub.  I have an appt this week with a new Doc so wish us luck. grrr. this gets so frustrating. 
    
(deactivated member)
on 8/25/11 9:26 am - Santa Cruz, CA
Has your DD been checked for a food allergy?  I have a friend who had the same horrible gas
problem (along with other symptoms) and she was finally diagnosed with a form of celiac sen-
sitivity, which is anything with gluten.  She avoids all manner of gluten-bearing foods and her'
health has really improved.

Good luck!
thenecklacelady
on 8/25/11 11:48 am
 My goodness I was just thinking the same thing; celiac disease.  
      
BeautyisherGODgiven
name

on 8/25/11 1:47 am
without actually reading the book, I am not sure what the controversy is. Is it the fact she is on a diet? Diet is the way she or anyone eats. Is it because she exercises; we don't want want them to? Chances are if a child is overweight others kids are pointing it out.
Follow my progress: www.youtube.com/user/livictori                           
    
M M
on 8/25/11 11:44 am
 Promoting a weight loss plan for a child?
Most Active
Hi, new here
JessieDays · 1 replies · 499 views
×