can I mix unflavored protein powder with V8?

shirleyfhoffman
on 5/21/11 12:11 pm - CA
I am just wondering if I can mix unflavored protein powder with V8 and count it as a shake? Can I also count it towards my fluid? Also, I don't know if I dump, but would the V8 make me dump?

 
  
HW:340 SW: 292 CW:164 GW: 140-130

DeeNadj
on 5/21/11 12:29 pm - Malmstrom AFB, MT
Even if it says "mix with anything" some protein powders are milk based and wouldn't taste very good mixed with "anything". I have one from GNC that is milk based and it's FABULOUS with hot tea (I love milk in my tea) or soups, but I can't mix that one with Crystal Light or juice of any kind.

And count your carbs - I try not to go over 15 carbs in a meal or a drink. But I'm on week 8 and cannot have ANY fruit or vegetable juice, per my NUT. That being said, I count whatever I put my protein in as part of my liquid if it's not something like soup mixed into a recipe. It IS part of your liquid if you're mixing it with something liquid, I think!
Dee
RNY March 21, 2011!! I'm feeling great!!
Busy Mommy of 4, Proud USAF Wife, Quilter, and TRIATHLETE!!               
Cicerogirl, The PhD
Version

on 5/21/11 12:38 pm - OH
Protein powder in V8 sounds absolutely disgusting to me, but I see no reason that you couldn't do it if you can actually drink it, LOL!  Even people who dump do not generally dump on natural sugar... and according to the label on my bottle of regular V8 there is no added sugar, so all the sugar must come from the veggies (the beets, I'm guessing) and shouldn't cause a problem.

Keep in mind the high sodium content, though.  (I don't personally worry about one item with high sodium, but I know some people do.)

Yes, V8 would count towards your fluids.  Some surgeons tell people not to count protein shakes as fluids, but they ARE liquids, so I have no idea why....

Lora

14 years out; 190 pounds lost, 165 pound loss maintained

You don't drown by falling in the water. You drown by staying there.

PatXYZ
on 5/21/11 2:04 pm
From what I understand, the minimum sugar content to trigger dumping is somewhere around 8-10g in a serving and is unusual below 12-15g. A glass of V8 is 9, so I would want to use a low or zero carb protein powder. I think it sounds awesome! Add a little pepper and yum!
shirleyfhoffman
on 5/21/11 4:25 pm - CA
I decided to try it. I mixed 1 tbs. with 2oz. of V8. I can't really taste a difference! If I were to drink 8oz with a scoop of the protein powder, it would be 27g of protein. If I mixed it with 1%milk, I would have 35g of protein so I don't think I'll be doing the V8 protein shakes very often, but I'm glad to know that when I get sick of the sweet shakes, I can have a V8 shake either cold or warm. It kind of reminds me of a better tasting tomato soup.

 
  
HW:340 SW: 292 CW:164 GW: 140-130

hazelnut6
on 5/21/11 8:16 pm
I used to mix my unflavored Unjury with tomato soup....it really wasn't that bad.  (for soup you have to watch the temperature...it can't be too hot)





Price S.
on 5/21/11 9:40 pm - Mills River, NC
V8 with protein powder was on our approved list pretty early out.  Nothing wrong with it and it gets you away from all the sweet stuff if you need a break from that.

    LW-Apple-Gold-Small.jpg image by PlicketyCat  66 yrs young, 4'11"  hw  220, goal 120 met at 12 months, cw 129 learning Maintainance

Between 35-40 BMI? join us on the Lightweight board.  the Lightweight Board
      
 

Most Active
Finally Friday's Menu
ladygodiva1228 · 4 replies · 166 views
Put Myself First
FloridaMom1994 · 1 replies · 140 views
Keep my Promise
FloridaMom1994 · 1 replies · 112 views
Taking the Next Step
FloridaMom1994 · 1 replies · 69 views
One Step closer
FloridaMom1994 · 0 replies · 42 views
Recent Topics
One Step closer
FloridaMom1994 · 0 replies · 42 views
Taking the Next Step
FloridaMom1994 · 1 replies · 69 views
Keep my Promise
FloridaMom1994 · 1 replies · 112 views
×