Peanuts and peanut butter Really????? No........

I can only do the all natural PB. Jiff or skipy make me feel like crap and that I have a piece of lead in my pouch. I don't eat it as much as I did preop, and when I do, I only do a very small amount on a piece of toast, less then a serving size.  I would wait a bit and then try it again.

Peanut butter bothered me REALLY bad in the beginning, but I can eat it now with no problem at all.

I am really fortunate, I can eat peanut butter and eat regular peanut butter.  (I make protein balls with peanut butter and protein powder that have alot of protein).  What makes me feel nauseous, makes my heart race and I have to sleep it off is sugar alcohols..unfortunately even small amounts recently. Frustrating since I use to really enjoy a couple of sugar free popsicles.  :(  I'm sorry to hear it isn't agreeing with you, but like previous posters I would try natural and if that doesn't work, try it again after some time. Good luck to you!