Nip Tuck!
I think it depends on a LOT of factors. But it doesn't matter what type of surgery you have, it's the weight loss itself that counts. However, there are some things that will most likely leave you with more skin than others.....obviously, the more your skin has been stretched by the weight will affect it, but also smoking, being older (the skin looses elasticsity (sp? sorry) as we get older) both affect how much the skin "snaps back" as well. My personal opinion is that exercise helps some with this, because you're "filling out" the extra skin with lean muscle, but again, just my opinion.

HW: 258lbs SW: 240 CW: 140 I am 5 foot 7 and 30 years old
VSG 12/21/10 Plastics: Tummy tuck, breast lift, and augmentation 11/3/11
Soon to be veterinarian!! xoxo