POLL: Do you take calcium/D3? What is your favorite form?

Ms. Poker Face
on 1/14/12 1:13 am
Alright, so I just searched through old posts to figure out what type of calcium we need (Citrate, NOT carbonate which isn't absorbed by our bodies).  I like the chewy bites, so I just ordered some off bariatric advantage... for $18 with shipping!  Yikes!  For 60 chews!  Ouch.  Anyhow, I thought I'd do a poll.

1) Do you take a calcium supplement?  If so, does it also contain D3?
2) What is your favorite brand or type?


 

5'5"    Goal reached, but fighting regain.  Back to Basics.
Start Weight 246    Goal Weight 160    Current Weight 183

Starting size: 22, 2x
Current size: 12, L

 

Happy Camper
on 1/14/12 1:19 am
 I just bought the sugar free calcium chews from Costco and love them!  They are 500mg + vitamins D & k.  I like the caramel flavored. 
            
doggz109
on 1/14/12 1:25 am - CA
VSG on 01/12/12
I would like to know also.  Seems kind of hard to find a good chewable calcium citrate unless you order online.
Crabadams72
on 1/14/12 1:31 am - Silver Spring, MD
I take either Citral petites or Upcal D. It is a dissolvable powder and you can add it to liquids or foods. It is commonly used in nursing homes. I order a large box from Amazon and it is cheaper than the chews.

Sadly I am bad w taking calcium but my labs look good.
VSG 6/10/2011  Dr. Ann Lidor BMore MD 5'5 HW-247 SW-233 GW-145 CW-120
        
http://www.youtube.com/user/72Crabadams   Me rambling about my journey : )

tillmadd
on 1/14/12 1:33 am - WI
 I buy Citrical + D3 from Walgreens...they are usually 13.99 for 60 chews ...i have found sales buy one get one 1/2 off. They often have $2.00 of coupons too! The fruity chews taste pretty good!
HW 314    SW 297 Thanks for the season Packers! 15-2!!
**CW 234 month 1-23 month 2-14 month 3-13 month 4-11 
           
   
           
(deactivated member)
on 1/14/12 1:37 am
I do this liquid blueberry stuff. I'm too lazy to get up and see what brand it is but it's in a brown bottle and I get it at a health food store for 7 dollars.  It's liquid citrate with magnesium citrate + D and it tastes like blueberry yogurt. I tried 2 chewables and they were so bad I couldn't take them.
Crabadams72
on 1/14/12 1:39 am - Silver Spring, MD
Tillmad-are they calcium citrate?

That is what we WLS patients need. I never see the right calcium in stores.
tillmadd
on 1/14/12 1:46 am - WI
 yes calcium citrate + D3 in many of our pharmacutical stores walmart/walgreens not sure about other stores? It is much cheaper than what  I see on line
HW 314    SW 297 Thanks for the season Packers! 15-2!!
**CW 234 month 1-23 month 2-14 month 3-13 month 4-11 
           
   
           
Fangirl_says
on 1/14/12 4:57 am - NC
I'm confused -- what is better about the calcium citrate? I've been taking Caltrate soft chews, which is calcium carbonate, but my levels have been good. Do I need to switch to something else? This is the first I've heard about this!
     
doggz109
on 1/14/12 6:55 am - CA
VSG on 01/12/12
Calcium citrate does not need stomach acid to be absored.....calcium carbonate does.  It all depends on the individual.

RNY patients absolutely NEED citrate....many surgeons say sleeve patients can do fine with either.  However, if your labs are low or you take any type of PPI that might lower your acid production then I would stick with citrate.
Most Active
×