Help! Dress dilemma

I never thought I'd be in a position to have FOUR dresses to choose from!  I love spring, lightweight dresses but could never find any cute ones in plus sizes.  Now that I'm on the verge of normal sizing, I find I have some options finally!  The first two are career/night-out appropriate depending on accessories.  I really like them both.  The last two are from Target and are just simple things to toss on when it gets ridiculously hot in Florida.  Opinions???  I'm tempted to get the first two now because I can "under-grow" into them over the next few months.  They're on ebay.  The other two are from Target and will probably (hopefully) be available for a while so I can get them later (not to mention they're 25 bucks each for some ungodly reason).  I would just like to hear y'alls opinions.  Thanks! Would be wearing a cami under this one.

I really love the first blue one and it would look great on you. I like the black & white one too, but I'm wondering if the sleeves are a tad long? You could always have them taken up I suppose - I just finished watching an episode of What Not to Wear and Stacy & Clinton are big fans of tailoring ;)  And the Target ones look just right for tossing on when the weather gets oppressive. I might not be the right person to ask about dresses though, because I love them all. I have FOURTEEN of them in my closet at the moment!

I *heart* you for your love of dresses!  I think the sleeves are long because it's kimono style.  There's a fluffy satin bow in the back where it ties too.  I'd have to see where they hit me to know if it bothers me.

I like that show....if it weren't for my wife and kids, alot of people might assume I were G-A-Y!

I won't tell anyone.  It just means you're enlightened LOL

I like the first one and the last one..

Thanks!  Always nice to get a guy reply!

LOVE LOVE LOVE the first one!  The shape is really flattering and I just like it a lot.  Isn't it great to have options!

I'm gonna join the crowd in saying LOVE the first one. The ones from Target look fun too. Have fun shopping!

I like the first dress better than the second- I feel like the style of the second doesn't flatter many figures, and I also like louder colors and styles. The other two dresses are great, esp. for florida- I favor the blue, but your features are definitely dark enough to pull off yellow as well