new whey?

poet_kelly
on 9/1/14 7:26 am - OH

Yeah.  the PCDAAS is a measurement of the digestibility of protein based on the amino acids.  Collagen is an incomplete protein, meaning it is missing some amino acids.  So in this brand of protein shot, they add a tiny bit of whey, which is a complete protein, and then they can truthfully say it has all the amino acids.  But not in the right amounts.

An egg has a PCDAAS of 1.0, the highest score you can get.  So does whey isolate protein powder.

Most of these protein shots that are mostly collagen have a score of something like 0.03 or 0.04.  That is barely better than zero.

You can, however, make your own protein shots.  Mix a scoop of protein powder in about three ounces of liquid.  It will be thick and have a very strong taste - just like these shots.  But if you are going to drink three or four ounces of thick, icky-tasting liquid, you might as well at least get some decent protein from it.

Or, as Lora suggests, try the Yes Whey brand from Bariatric Advantage, the only one I'm aware of out there that is all whey protein and therefore actually a good source of protein.

View more of my photos at ObesityHelp.com          Kelly

Please note: I AM NOT A DOCTOR.  If you want medical advice, talk to your doctor.  Whatever I post, there is probably some surgeon or other health care provider somewhere that disagrees with me.  If you want to know what your surgeon thinks, then ask him or her.    Check out my blog.

 

eringudge
on 9/2/14 4:36 am
RNY on 07/28/14

Unjury and Syntrax Nectar are both 100% whey protein isolate as well, just to let you know. :) 

noftessa0401
on 9/2/14 9:08 am - San Diego, CA
RNY on 12/27/12

I think she means the protein shots (Yes Whey that you can buy at Bariatric Advantage) - the ones with 42g of protein in a 3 ounce shot - are the only protein shots that are 100% whey protein isolate.  There are a LOT of protein shakes/powders/supplements out there that are 100% whey protein isolate.  But the only SHOTS that have 100% whey protein isolate are Yes Whey from Bariatric Advantage. 

HW: 274 | SW: 232 | CW: 137 | Goal: 145 (ticker includes a 42 pound loss pre-op) | Height: 5'4"

M1: -24 (205) | M2: -14 (191) | M3: -11 (180) | M4: -7 (173) | M5: -7 (166) | M6: -8 (158) | M7: -11 (147) | M8: -2 (145) | M9: -3 (142) | M10: -2 (140) | M11: -4 (136) | M12: -2 (134) | M13: -0 (134) | M14: -3 (131) | M15: +4 (135) | M16: +2 (137)

Cicerogirl, The PhD
Version

on 9/1/14 12:06 am - OH

They are disgusting in both taste and texture, IMO.  More importantly, contain mostly collagen protein that is very little use to you.  

If you want to try one of the protein shots, get the Yes Whey brand which is 100% whey protein and isn't slimy.

Lora

14 years out; 190 pounds lost, 165 pound loss maintained

You don't drown by falling in the water. You drown by staying there.

jenorama
on 9/1/14 2:59 am - CA
RNY on 10/07/13

Those things are indeed the worst. I had to do them once a day on my 2 days of liquids pre-op. Hands down the most terrible thing about the process. Worse than getting cut open, post-op pain and constipation. I look at those little capsules and a tiny voice in my brain cries out "Noooooooooo..."

Jen

MegZorar
on 9/1/14 3:31 am

YIKES! Glad I asked. Thanks for letting me know.

     

MegZorar
on 9/1/14 3:29 am

I will check it out. Thanks. ****rogirl.

     

TexasLady52
on 9/2/14 5:44 am
Revision on 06/10/14

Stopped one day and bought 10.....got home and could not get pass the smell and tast "GAG"!   Took nine back and got my money back!

MegZorar
on 9/2/14 1:48 pm

Woa! Glad I asked. Thanks for the input.

     

TexasLady52
on 9/2/14 5:47 am
Revision on 06/10/14

Try ......

Genepro http://www.musclegen.net/ .... it is oderless and tasteless and does not clump.  You can add it to hot or cold....or just sprinkle over your food.  This stuff is great.  One tablespoon equals a scoop of Whey and has 30 grams of protein.  It is approved by John Hopkins and has 96% absorbtion.  You can also order it from Amazon.  I go by every morning to a  shake shop....get a Chunky Monkey (35 grams of protein).....add a scoop of Genepro (30 grams of protein)....mid morning I fix a Crystal Light and add another scoop.....I already have 95 grams for the day!!!  You can contact the website for a free sample.

Most Active
×