When does depression set in?
RNY on 09/17/12
As someone who IS and HAS been diagnosed with clinical depression I agree with all of you.
Depression is not a minor disease. It is complex and confusing. It doesn't have a blood test that can tell you that you are depressed and medicating it is very difficult. It open can take months or years to find a medication or combination of medicines that work. (and then when you least expect it - a new study shows that your medication has serious cardiac side effects... and then you start the process all over again - ugh, I'm just going through that now!)
I hate that the Rx's are advertised on TV, it almost makes light of the disease that is so difficult for many of us to handle. It also gives people that impression that it is NOT a serious condition.
I think the drugs are way over prescribed. I can even say that they can over prescribe to us who do clinical depression - my first doctor had me taking NINE pills a day - I was basically a zombie. Thank god for finding a doctor that can help and my medications were severely cut back.
Depression is not a minor disease. It is complex and confusing. It doesn't have a blood test that can tell you that you are depressed and medicating it is very difficult. It open can take months or years to find a medication or combination of medicines that work. (and then when you least expect it - a new study shows that your medication has serious cardiac side effects... and then you start the process all over again - ugh, I'm just going through that now!)
I hate that the Rx's are advertised on TV, it almost makes light of the disease that is so difficult for many of us to handle. It also gives people that impression that it is NOT a serious condition.
I think the drugs are way over prescribed. I can even say that they can over prescribe to us who do clinical depression - my first doctor had me taking NINE pills a day - I was basically a zombie. Thank god for finding a doctor that can help and my medications were severely cut back.
RNY on 08/14/12
Yes, it makes total sense. :)
This is definitely not wanting to feel my emotions--I've been feeling them for too long and it became overwhelming. In my situation, the medication has helped me see things more clearly, and more willing to face things without that black cloud hovering over my head. ;)
This is definitely not wanting to feel my emotions--I've been feeling them for too long and it became overwhelming. In my situation, the medication has helped me see things more clearly, and more willing to face things without that black cloud hovering over my head. ;)
I am so glad you are feeling good and upbeat ... how awesome is that! Many people do not experience post op depression at all ... a bit of anxiety and sometimes even frustration may be experienced the first few days/weeks while adjusting ... even a bit of sadness or sense of loss may be experienced occasionally but it is not clinical depression. I was not depressed at all .. I did wonder though 'what the heck did I do to myself?' the first few weeks out...LOL
I never had ANYTHING I could complain about - no pain, nausea, depression, difficulty eating etc ...
I do feel that sometimes because you read these forums it could be almost disappointing that you don't have anything to moan about - especially as some people seem to get all the complications and therefore all the attention!!!!
We should congratulate ourselves for doing well!!!!
I do feel that sometimes because you read these forums it could be almost disappointing that you don't have anything to moan about - especially as some people seem to get all the complications and therefore all the attention!!!!
We should congratulate ourselves for doing well!!!!
Proud Feminist, Atheist, LGBT friend, and Democratic Socialist
RNY on 07/18/12
On August 20, 2012 at 6:52 AM Pacific Time, Sin Kim wrote:
I never had ANYTHING I could complain about - no pain, nausea, depression, difficulty eating etc ... I do feel that sometimes because you read these forums it could be almost disappointing that you don't have anything to moan about - especially as some people seem to get all the complications and therefore all the attention!!!!
We should congratulate ourselves for doing well!!!!
RNY on 05/09/12
I am not a doctor of any kind so please do not take my comments to the bank. But I have a retired friend who was in private practice in the Chicago area and now lives in Arizona. I talk to him for an hour almost every day via amateur radio (Ham). He does not offer me medical advise, but just gives me his opinion which anyone in our country can do. And I simple repeat his opinions here so I am not giving medical advise when I give my opinion. But he did relate to me several times that before the suppliers started advertising heavily on TV he seldom had people coming in complaining of depression. After the ads started, it was like the flood gates where opened. He said most people were simply sad about something in their lives but because of the influence of the TV advertisements, they demanded medications.
People will say I have been diagnosed with clinical depression for years, if so OK, but just because your PCP gave you medications does not equate to a complex evaluation by someone qualified to do so. Remember once on the drug, it may be very difficult if not nearly impossible to get off them with warnings that you may be susceptible to suicide if you stop.
Have you ever heard, “I am so depressed my dog died“. “I am so depressed I did not lose any weight this week“. “I am so depressed my hair is falling out“. Lets us resolve to replace the word depressed with Sad, to try to eliminate the confusion. True depression is very very serious and it is not sadness. If you legitimately feel you are depressed please go to specialists who will do a complete workup on you and verify that you have a condition that only medications can help. Maybe counseling or other treatments will be of more help in the long run.
Again this is just my opinion yours may be different I am not a doctor just an old man who has watched the depression spiral our of control, real or not.
People will say I have been diagnosed with clinical depression for years, if so OK, but just because your PCP gave you medications does not equate to a complex evaluation by someone qualified to do so. Remember once on the drug, it may be very difficult if not nearly impossible to get off them with warnings that you may be susceptible to suicide if you stop.
Have you ever heard, “I am so depressed my dog died“. “I am so depressed I did not lose any weight this week“. “I am so depressed my hair is falling out“. Lets us resolve to replace the word depressed with Sad, to try to eliminate the confusion. True depression is very very serious and it is not sadness. If you legitimately feel you are depressed please go to specialists who will do a complete workup on you and verify that you have a condition that only medications can help. Maybe counseling or other treatments will be of more help in the long run.
Again this is just my opinion yours may be different I am not a doctor just an old man who has watched the depression spiral our of control, real or not.
Visit my Blog at http://www.lwassmann.blogspot.com/
RNY on 08/14/12
Nope, I totally agree! It has been overly diagnosed, just like some other health conditions. TV ads have not helped, IMO.
I was diagnosed by my psychiatrist and therapist, and I really should have been diagnosed when I was much younger. I hid my symptoms very well, so no one ever thought I had any problems. I finally had a break, when I couldn't keep things together anymore, so that's when I sought out expert diagnoses, rather than through my PCP. My PCP is very hands-on, so she likes to keep tabs on how I'm managing my depression, but she doesn't prescribe for me. She agrees with me to see the psychiatrist for medication maintenance.
I took medication for about a year and a half, and then weaned myself off. Then I had my daughter, and the hormones made me very anxious and set me back to being on meds again. I'm actually hoping that I can get off of them in a while. There's nothing wrong in those who need to take them, but I don't want to take them forever, honestly. That's just my opinion. ;)
I was diagnosed by my psychiatrist and therapist, and I really should have been diagnosed when I was much younger. I hid my symptoms very well, so no one ever thought I had any problems. I finally had a break, when I couldn't keep things together anymore, so that's when I sought out expert diagnoses, rather than through my PCP. My PCP is very hands-on, so she likes to keep tabs on how I'm managing my depression, but she doesn't prescribe for me. She agrees with me to see the psychiatrist for medication maintenance.
I took medication for about a year and a half, and then weaned myself off. Then I had my daughter, and the hormones made me very anxious and set me back to being on meds again. I'm actually hoping that I can get off of them in a while. There's nothing wrong in those who need to take them, but I don't want to take them forever, honestly. That's just my opinion. ;)