Protein shake or bar?

averybyrd
on 9/23/13 7:31 am

For those of you who were told to get additional protein through whey, which do you prefer? I just started trying the bars, and I think I prefer them at the moment. I get to eat, which satisfies that emotional/mental "need," plus I was sick and tired of my shake. 

The calories on the bars are slightly higher, which is sad, and they take longer to eat because I can only get in 1/2 at a sitting. 

Which do you like better? Is there an advantage or disadvantage I'm overlooking?

Mark W.
on 9/23/13 7:47 am - belle plaine, MN

My favorite is the EAS Carb control protein shake pre-made. They're super easy, grab and go and most of them are only 100 calories. This for me has been a good source of water and protein (17g) each. So far as bars go, I love the Atkins peanut and chocolate bars. Super yummy but haven't experienced yet with Sugar Alcohols so I have no idea what role they will play with my new system. Usually they can cause diarrhea when taken in higher amounts.

    

            

Katie K.
on 9/23/13 8:21 am - Maitland, FL
RNY on 06/25/13
You can add unflavored whey to soups and such. Unjury makes a chicken soup flavor that is to die for, especially if you're sick of sweet flavors.

I have a protein shake for breakfast because food makes me feel pukey for a few hours if I eat breakfast. I probably should have another shake at night because I don't think I'm getting all my protein in.

My program says no protein bars because they're glorified candy bars. Power Crunch bars are soooo tasty, though.

    

    
PetHairMagnet
on 9/23/13 9:34 am
RNY on 05/13/13

It really depends on what I am in the mood for. I was buying the Detour low sugar bars and then all of a sudden (I mean same day!) I went from liking them to finding them disgustingly sweet a few months out. Now I rotate between four flavors of Quest bars, which are less sweet to me. My husband swears they are just as sweet. 

    

HW333--SW 289--GW of 160 5' 11" woman.  I only know the way I know & when you ask for input/advice, you'll get the way I've been successful through my surgeon & nutritionist. Please consult your surgeon & nutritionist for how to do it their way.  Biggest regret? Not doing this 10 years ago! Every day is better than the day before...and it was a pretty great day!

        

    

    

Mary Catherine
on 9/23/13 9:41 am
Quest protein bars, and I only eat the ones with no sugar alcohols. Your body does not care if the protein comes from a shake or a bar or meat or chicken or fish or soy. Protein is protein.
kinny09
on 9/23/13 9:55 am - New York, NY
RNY on 06/11/13

Shakes because many of the brands are no carb and low or no sugar, just a better deal and usually more protein through the shakes as well.

  HW: 306         Day of Surgery: 299         Current Weight: 172

    

    

marissasmith1987
on 9/23/13 10:47 am - troy, NY
RNY on 01/13/14

i like premier protien shakes 160 cal 30grams protein and taste good 

- Marissa RYN 1-13-14. If the past was perfect then there would be no need for tomorrow

    

    

        

Most Active
Recent Topics
×