Carbonated Beverages...Again

Sylvie G.
on 5/15/13 5:25 am - Monroeville, IN
RNY on 04/16/13

Big smiley face over here :). If its uncomfortable to drink, then don't drink it. Also, I'm a month out. I don't think I would try it any sooner then that. Tummy does need time to heal before giving it bubbles. I don't plan on drink Perrier all the time but its a nice change from plain water and sweet drinks. I'm enjoying one now. 

Referral - 12/21/12, Referral Received - 1/10/13, Orientation - 1/21/13, Met Dr. Hagen - 2/20/13, NUT, RN, SW - 3/13/13, Gastroscopy - 3/13/13, Dr. Glazer - 3/21/13, Pick-up Opti - 3/21/13, PATTS - 3/21/13, Surgery - 4/16/13

 

    

sublimechick
on 5/15/13 5:27 am - Canada

Great to know!!! I think Perrier would be an excellent treat. I guess more cannot tolerate than can eh? Interesting. 

 Referral sent Sept 2012 -Info Session -January 7 2013.  Surgeon (Dr. Huynh-HRRH) February 5 2013. Dr. Glazer, Nurse, SW and NUT -> March 25 2013, May 1st, Surgeon, Patts-June 6. SURGERY JUNE 26 2013!! 100 lbs gone in 4 months!

        

funkyphillygirl
on 5/15/13 5:53 am

My sense is that every surgeon (and their team) has very difference views on the carbonated beverage debate.  Before my surgery (20 months ago - RNY), the nutritionists were (and still are) VERY anti-any carbonated beverage.  My surgeon has been MUCH more middle of the road about it all - he said that if I wanted it and could tolerate it, it would be an OK thing on occasion.  He has been much more concerned about finding a lifestyle that is comfortable for me and keeps my weight stable.

For me, it's been nice to know that I could have it if I wanted it.  I still haven't - and it's been 22 months without carbonated beverages, but it's still nice to know.  I know how much I love Diet Coke and think it would be hard for me to just have it once in a while, so I'm still off of it.  I might treat myself someday, but I'm also trying to keep going without it.

Sorry you got beat up when you brought it up previously!

kayakgirl
on 5/15/13 5:53 am - Canada

Here's to your hutzpah, Sylvie! The nasty comments you received before were way out of line. You showed them!!!! Woot! Woot!

Initial referral: March 21, 2013; Orientation: April 26, 2013 (OWMC); Nurse Practitioner: July 10, 2013; Nut/Beh: July 15, 2013; Pre-op Class: September 18, 2013; Internist: September 18, 2013; Surgeon: October 1, 2013; Surgery: November 25, 2013 (Dr. Yelle)

    

    

    
Diminishing Dawn
on 5/15/13 6:32 am - Windsor, Canada

The "carbonated beverages" issue is such a HUGE expectation of the Ontario Bariatric program, that it is outlined on their webpage:

http://www.ontariobariatricnetwork.ca/faq.aspx

Carbonated beverages can cause problems after surgery, as they produce gas in the small stomach pouch. Most people find this very painful. You need to stop drinking carbonated drinks 2 months before surgery to get you use to not drinking carbonated drinks after surgery.

No one is trying to lead you astray here on this one.  This has been preached since the inception of their program in 2009. 

That said, your surgeon or centre may have a more "permissive" attitude when it comes to carbonated beverages.   It's surprising as most surgeons in Ontario say a resounding NO on this one.  (I had surgery in the states and was allowed to have them past the initial period).  The surgeons in Ontario must just be starting to change their views on this idea because this is the FIRST time I've ever seen it posted that a surgeon said it was okay....in the last 4 years. What surgeon was it?

The thing is that this philosophy is NOT UNCOMMON throughout the world, not just Ontario. You will have some surgeons that believe that carbonated beverages stretch the pouch. It is one of the "unknowns" of surgery.  

Dawn

 

17+ years post op RNY. first year blog here or My LongTimer blog. Tummy Tuck Dr. Matic 2014 -Ohip funded panni Windsor WLS support group.message me anytime!
HW:290 LW:139 RW: 167 CW: 139

Marny B.
on 5/15/13 9:33 am, edited 5/15/13 9:34 am - Canada

I don't think your quote from above says it is strictly off limits for everyone.  It says that it CAN cause gas main and that MOST people cannot tolerate it, so it is better to get used to not having it.  My guidelines were that I can have Carbonated beverages if I tolerate them well.  I do, from time too time, have diet pop(maybe once or twice a month). I absolutely cannot drink pop out of a can, but fountain pop causes me no discomfort at all.

 

Referral Sent:  March 19, 2010
Surgery date with Dr. Denis Hong: December 9, 2010

    
    
          
                                                        

Diminishing Dawn
on 5/15/13 9:43 am - Windsor, Canada

Yes I realize that.  I've been through two orientations for windsor and they are pretty adamant.  Surprised. 

17+ years post op RNY. first year blog here or My LongTimer blog. Tummy Tuck Dr. Matic 2014 -Ohip funded panni Windsor WLS support group.message me anytime!
HW:290 LW:139 RW: 167 CW: 139

Marny B.
on 5/15/13 11:53 am - Canada

Wanting to add that, my use of capitals was not meant at all to be snippy, just to highlight the words that stood out as offering a loophole in the "no carbonated beverages" rule.  

Also Wanted to ask what you were surprised at: that Windsor has such a strict policy on it?

Referral Sent:  March 19, 2010
Surgery date with Dr. Denis Hong: December 9, 2010

    
    
          
                                                        

Diminishing Dawn
on 5/15/13 12:07 pm - Windsor, Canada

Surprised that after the last four years of "no carbonation allowed" rules in Ontario that Hagen is all of a sudden going against the grain.  

 

17+ years post op RNY. first year blog here or My LongTimer blog. Tummy Tuck Dr. Matic 2014 -Ohip funded panni Windsor WLS support group.message me anytime!
HW:290 LW:139 RW: 167 CW: 139

birdiegirl
on 5/15/13 8:51 pm

Hi Dawn

I have attended several orientations in Hamilton- as recently as this week....and they are also strictly in the "no carbonation" camp....and that is from Anvari who is the head of Bariatric in Ontario

 

Saying all of this....I will have the occasional low carb beer....by occasional I mean I have had under 10 of them in 4 years....and I didnt touch carbonation until I was post 2 years.....

As for diet pop....I will never drink it again......just read too many horror stories and tales of people gaining....not sure of the physiology of this....and its anecdotal...however....I have read of many more post ops indicate they wish they never started diet pop- then those who drink it with no ill effects.....

 

Each to his own....we all have to choose our route in this journey....for me though...I dont want to buck the system too much....

         

        

 

 

 
  

Most Active
Recent Topics
Plastic Surgeon near Toronto
Jellybean1414 · 1 replies · 430 views
Spring Clothing Exchange!!!
Mallory · 2 replies · 456 views
POSSIBLE GET TOGETHER??????
lexxiblue · 5 replies · 534 views
Fall Clothing Exchange!!!
Mallory · 1 replies · 554 views
Forms
Canadianblues2000 · 0 replies · 667 views
×